Stryker Hip Replacements: Failures, Recalls & Safety Concerns
Stryker’s metal-on-metal hip implants have faced recalls, lawsuits and regulatory scrutiny due to severe health risks. Patients reported implant failures, metallosis and systemic complications. Legal settlements and FDA actions ultimately led to the decline of these devices in the U.S.
Why Have Stryker Hip Replacements Faced Safety Issues?
Stryker hip replacements, especially the LFIT V40 femoral heads and certain adjustable parts like the Rejuvenate and ABG II, have had safety concerns because of problems in their design and materials. These issues can lead to serious hip replacement complications such as corrosion, harmful metal buildup in the body and wear and tear of the replacement parts.
Metal-on-metal (MoM) hip implants like the recalled Stryker implants, have a high failure rate. They often become loose, increasing friction that may lead to many issues, including metallosis. Metallosis is a type of metal poisoning that happens when the surfaces of the implants wear down over time.
Stryker LFIT V40 Corrosion and Metallosis
Stryker’s LFIT V40 taper system combined cobalt-chromium (CoCr) femoral heads and titanium alloy stems. This pairing can cause a problem called galvanic corrosion, leading to faster wear of the components. It led to a 2016 recall of more than 42,000 units manufactured before March 2011.
A 2014 study in the Journal of Arthroplasty found that material loss from the CoCr heads could reach 4.3 cubic millimeters, primarily due to corrosion between the parts.
Lawsuits claimed that the Stryker LFIT V40 experienced higher-than-average taper lock failure, which is when the implant fails at the hip joint because the femoral head has gotten loose. This can lead to problems like tiny metal particles and ions being released, which may cause metallosis.
Metallosis can damage bone and other tissue near the implant, potentially leading to severe conditions like tissue damage or death.
Stryker ABG II and Rejuvenate Hip Implants
A global Stryker hip implant recall affected the company’s ABG II and Rejuvenate Modular Hip Systems in 2012 due to risks of fretting (tiny shards of metal entering the bloodstream, tissues and bones) and corrosion at the modular neck junction.
This caused tissue reactions, pain, swelling or bone loss, potentially requiring revision surgery — removing and replacing the joint. Patients with these implants had to be monitored closely, especially if experiencing pain or swelling. Surgeons and healthcare providers were told to follow up with affected patients.
Symptoms of Implant Failure and Metallosis
Faulty MoM implants can cause localized issues like pain, lowered mobility and inflammation. This inflammation may harm nearby soft tissues and ultimately result in the implant’s failure.
- Sounds Coming From Your Hip: You shouldn’t hear sounds from your hip, so popping, clicking, squeaking or other noises can indicate failure.
- Pain in the Hip or Groin: Persistent pain may signal implant loosening or tissue damage, even while resting.
- Swelling and Inflammation: Tissue irritation from metal debris can cause noticeable swelling.
- Reduced Mobility or Instability: Walking difficulties or weakness can suggest implant loosening.
- Pseudotumors: Soft tissue masses may develop, causing discomfort and movement issues.
- Numbness Around the Joint: Nerve compression from swelling can lead to loss of sensation.
These local complications can escalate if left unaddressed, and metal ions may enter the bloodstream, triggering widespread health effects.
- Elevated Metal Ion Levels: Increased cobalt and chromium in the blood can cause toxicity.
- Organ Dysfunction: Metal exposure can impact your skin, kidney, thyroid, heart and liver function.
- Bone Loss (Osteolysis): Metal debris can weaken bones, increasing the risk of implant failure.
- Neuropsychiatric Symptoms: Patients with metallosis may show signs of depression and cognitive decline.
Studies looking for links between metallosis and cancer have had mixed results.
It’s important to catch metallosis symptoms early on. See a doctor immediately if you have these issues.
When your doctor looks for problems with the implant or signs of metallosis, they may order X-rays or other imaging and blood tests.
If your MoM hip fails due to metallosis, the only treatment is revision surgery. This involves removing and replacing the defective implant with a new hip replacement.
Legal & Regulatory Actions Against Stryker
The FDA’s fast-track approval process, the 510(k) Premarket Notification Process, allowed Stryker’s hip implants to reach patients without extensive safety testing. As failures mounted, regulators tightened restrictions, and lawsuits followed. Increased oversight and legal action ultimately forced companies to abandon metal-on-metal hip replacements in the United States.
FDA Actions & Safety Regulations
Stryker opted for a quicker FDA 510(k) fast-track process to win approval for the Rejuvenate and ABG II devices. With this approval route, companies only need to show that their medical device is similar to an existing one in the U.S. Extensive clinical trials aren’t required.
High failure rates and serious health problems from metal-on-metal (MoM) hip replacements made by several different manufacturers were reported frequently in the 2010s.
In February 2016, the FDA required companies to stop selling these devices unless they received special approval, effective May 2016. This lengthy and challenging approval process helps ensure the implants are safe and effective.
There are no FDA-approved MoM total hip replacement devices in the U.S., but there are two approved metal-on-metal hip resurfacing devices.
Lawsuits, Settlements & Global Responses
In addition to referencing the adverse effects of MoM implants, lawsuits claimed that Stryker knew that the combination of metals used in these devices, TMZF titanium alloy and cobalt-chromium, had caused issues with earlier products. Stryker hip replacement lawsuits claimed that the company continued using these designs despite their knowledge.
Stryker lawsuits over injuries from the ABG II and Rejuvenate hips were consolidated into multidistrict litigation (MDL) in 2013. MDLs consolidate several similar lawsuits into one to make the legal process more efficient.
Cases over the Stryker LFIT V40 taper device were combined in a separate MDL in 2017.
- MDL 2441:
- A Minnesota federal court consolidated over 40 ABG II and Rejuvenate lawsuits. The transfer order cited problems with Stryker's design, manufacturing, marketing and performance of the two devices. More than 3,600 lawsuits were filed in this MDL.
- MDL 2768:
- A federal panel consolidated six Stryker LFIT V40 hip lawsuits into an MDL in a Massachusetts federal court. The lawsuits claimed that the LFIT V40 could corrode at a connection point, mainly when used with different materials. The corrosion caused implant failure and serious health issues, requiring surgery to replace the device. More than 1,200 cases were filed in the MDL.
- Settlement Agreements:
- Stryker paid $1.4 billion to settle more than 5,000 Rejuvenate and ABG II lawsuits in 2014. In 2018, the company reached a confidential hip replacement settlement with the plaintiff’s attorneys in the LFIT V40 hip litigation.
What Patients With Stryker Hip Implants Should Do
Those who underwent hip replacement surgery before May 18, 2016, may have received a metal-on-metal implant. Your doctor should be able to tell you for sure.
If you have a Stryker or another brand of metal-on-metal hip implant, it’s important to have regular check-ups with your orthopedic doctor. Early detection can help avoid significant complications or the need for additional surgery later on.
- Schedule Regular Follow-Ups: See your surgeon as recommended and more frequently if advised after receiving imaging or blood test results.
- Monitor for Symptoms: Report any pain, swelling, numbness, weakness or changes in your ability to walk. Listen for unusual noises like popping, grinding or clicking.
- Discuss Health Changes: Inform your surgeon of any new medical conditions, treatments or general health concerns since receiving your implant.
- Request Testing if Concerned: Blood tests can check metal ion levels, and imaging can assess implant stability and tissue health.
If your symptoms get worse, reach out to your surgeon right away. Getting help can prevent severe problems, ensure your implant works appropriately and keep you healthy.
Online Resources for People With Metal-on-Metal Hips
The FDA and many other agencies, hospitals and non-profits provide information for patients with MoM implants. If you are unsure if you received a metal-on-metal hip implant or have any questions, please consult your doctor.
- Arthritis Foundation — Metal-on-Metal Hip Implant Risks
- This resource provides detailed information about the risks of MoM hip implants, including systemic effects and tissue damage. It also offers guidance on managing complications and understanding implant failure.
- FDA - Information for Patients on Metal-on-Metal Hip Implants
- The FDA provides a comprehensive guide for patients, including potential adverse effects, follow-up recommendations and advice on monitoring metal ion levels. It’s a reliable source for regulatory updates and safety communications.
- Mass General Center for Metal-on-Metal Hip & Tribocorrosion Evaluation & Treatment
- This medical center specializes in comprehensive care for patients with MoM hip implants, offering advanced diagnostic tools and treatments. It also conducts cutting-edge research on MoM implant failures and adverse reactions.
- Mayo Clinic Connect Joint Replacements Support Group
- This online community allows patients to share experiences, seek advice, and discuss issues related to MoM hip implants, such as revision surgeries and managing metal ion levels.
Calling this number connects you with a Drugwatch.com representative. We will direct you to one of our trusted legal partners for a free case review.
Drugwatch.com's trusted legal partners support the organization's mission to keep people safe from dangerous drugs and medical devices. For more information, visit our partners page.